Disabled Residents’ Earlier Council Tax Bills Face Review After Universal Credit Switch...

Hartlepool Borough Council Acknowledges Council Tax Calculation Issue Affecting Universal Credit Claimants..
20th November 2026
Disabled residents living in Hartlepool could have paid too much council tax after transitioning from legacy welfare benefits onto Universal Credit a council report has revealed, with a promised council review intended to identify affected cases.
Hartlepool Borough Council's acknowledged that it previously counted Universal Credit transitional protection as income when calculating council tax support. A decision recorded in March committed officers to reviewing earlier cases involving disability and taking further decisions once that work was complete.
Transitional protection is intended to cushion the move from older legacy benefits to Universal Credit by topping up an award where the new entitlement would otherwise be lower. Counting that top-up when assessing council tax support can leave a household facing a bigger bill even though its overall income has stayed the same.
The issue was brought before the High Court by disabled couple Lynn and David Bleakley, who challenged Three Rivers District Council after moving from Employment and Support Allowance to Universal Credit. Their income remained unchanged, but they became liable for 75% of their council tax bill.
Three Rivers conceded that its treatment of the couple amounted to unlawful disability discrimination. A consent order approved in February provided for £5,000 in damages, a £526 council tax refund and payment of their legal costs.
Hartlepool’s March decision followed that case, with officers estimating that disregarding transitional protection would affect around 100 claimants and cost approximately £40,000, based on the caseload at the time.
The decision said the council would examine cases where transitional protection had previously been counted as income and arose from a move to Universal Credit linked to disability. It stated that “further actions / decisions will be taken once this review has been completed.”
A report going before the councils Finance and Corporate Affairs Committee on Thursday 26th November confirms that the council has excluded transitional protection from income calculations for its 2026/27 scheme. The March decision applies that approach across working-age claims from 1st April 2026.
Officers now propose inserting explicit wording into the 2027/28 council tax reduction scheme to confirm how the payments will be treated. The November report says the correction was needed to ensure compliance with equality and human rights law.
The government also warned councils that differences in how their schemes assess older benefits, Universal Credit and transitional protection could leave some claimants losing council tax support despite their household income staying the same. It encouraged councils to consider the effects on households with low incomes and explain their approach to those affected.
The Teesside & Durham Post also understands that a Hartlepool resident has now submitted a claim for Judicial Review after a previous hearing in the 1st tier tribunal of the social security chamber ruling council tax deductions from a persons Universal Credit being 'unlawful' has not been complied with either by Hartlepool Borough Council or the Department for Work & Pensions.


